Winter green manure – advantages and disadvantages

1

Last Autumn I covered half of my allotment’s raised beds with regular horse manure, it was about three inches deep. We get free manure deliveries to our allotment site and it did a marvellous job of keeping the weeds down over the winter.  The crops that I grew in the various raised beds this year produced bumper crops but I was prevented from growing root crops (because the fertility can be too high if recently manured resulting in ‘funny veg’ syndrome). Consequently this winter I’ve gone with a green manure solution which involves sowing in mid to late September (October at a push).

What is ‘green manure’?

Digging in green manure

Digging in green manure

By ‘green manure’ we don’t mean manure from a very poorly horse… we mean that we sow a cover crop in a bed (or beds) with the sole purpose of letting it grow before we cut it down and turn or rotovate it into the soil (without harvesting any produce from it). Think of it as a sacrificial crop used to improve your soil – it sounds a bit bonkers but there are many reasons why we do it. An Autumn sowing of green manure will see plants grow throughout the winter before they are cut back and turned into the soil the following spring.

 


 

Green Manure Advantages:

  1. Some green manure crops can fix nitrogen and key soil nutrients into the soil so that they don’t leach out of the soil over the cold rainy autumn and winter months. Empty beds will leach nutrients.
  2. Other green manure crops can bring up nitrogen and minerals from deep in the soil into the plant foliage, which when cut back and rotovated, adds them into the soil for Spring planting.
  3. Green manure crops restrict weed growth, empty beds are likely to be overtaken by unwanted weeds which will draw nutrients from the soil and be a nuisance to remove the following year.
  4. Many green manure crops can help to break up heavy clay soil, those crops with a long tap root help to split large clumps of clay, making the soil easier to manage and cultivate.

Green Manure Disadvantages:

  1. A green manure crop may provide an environment for slugs and snails to breed in, which could increase their numbers (but then again so could weeds!).
  2. You have to allow up to four weeks after cutting back and rotovating the green manure crops before sowing a new crop. This is because some crops are allelopathic which means they naturally leave toxic substances in the soil to restrict the germination of other new crops. (NOTE. Coffee grounds also do this because of the caffeine!).
  3. Some varieties of mustard are commonly sold as green manure cover crops. Mustard is a brassica so if you are planning to grow cabbages, broccoli or cauliflowers in a bed it should not have been recently used to grow a mustard cover crop.

 

Landsberger Winter Mix

Landsberger Winter Mix

Personally I only ever sow green manure crops in mid Autumn to provide over-wintering benefits but you can sow many of them all year round. Since I typically need my allotment beds throughout spring and summer that rules out a green manure solution for me in peak growing season. Here below I have listed some common ‘Autumn sowing’ green manure crops but there are spring and summer sowing crops available with a bit of research. You can get away with sowing winter green manure crops through until around mid October, I once tried a November sowing of rye but that didn’t germinate very well:

  • Italian / Hungarian Grazing Rye – a nitrogen and mineral LIFTER that also works well as a soil structure improver. Can be left to grow for up to two years before cutting (if you feel like a year off at the allotment!).
  • Red Clover / Trifolium incarnatum – a nitrogen FIXER that also works well as a soil structure improver and is an excellent weed suppressant.
  • Forage Pea – a legume which is again a nitrogen FIXER and improves soil structure with its deep root system.
  • White Mustard (Sinapsis alba) – a fast growing brassica which covers the ground in just over one month. Mustard plants can ‘cleanse’ the soil of pathogens because they contain high levels of glucosinolates.
  • Winter Field Beans – a nitrogen FIXER, very hardy and excellent for breaking up heavy soils

 

Beds ready for sowing green manure

I don’t sow beans or peas as a cover crop on my allotment because we get a lot of pheasants at our site and they will destroy the shoots unless netted (and that isn’t practical for large areas). Pigeons can also be just as much of a nuisance so do factor in possible bird damage during colder months when other food sources are less available to birds. As a consequence I tend to go more for the Rye, Mustard and Clover based green manure mixes. As you can see (right) I have already begun to turn over the finished summer beds and sown some seeds already. It is important not to leave this too late because cold soil may restrict the germination of the green manure crops, leaving your soil exposed to the elements.

I have sown three different seed mixes, all purchased from an Irish company called Seedaholic:

I’ve also sown a mixture with added Phacelia tanacetifolia ‘Lacy Phacelia’ – I’m not entirely sure that will overwinter as it’s not very hardy but I thought I’d give it a whirl. Other mixes I’ve purchased in the past include those available from Pennard Plants priced at £3 for 22 sqm of coverage per pack. Pennards are a family run nursery which specialises in natural growing methods and heritage seeds. I have bought squash seeds and garlic bulbs from them for the past two years with much success. Seeds are also available from Thompson & Morgan who sell Crimson Clover and Grazing Rye at £2.99 per packet.

*** November 2017 UPDATE ***
Of the Seedaholic green manure seed mixes listed in the bullets above I found that the Landsberger mix grew best on my clay soil, the green manure winter mix is performing more slowly and the ‘Tares & Rye’ mix is growing least well. The Landsberger mix is growing in the middleground below, all sown around six weeks ago. I have just sown some more in the beds at the far end of the plot but cold weather is upon us so it may not germinate well.

Green manure progress: November 2017

Share.

About Author

Matt Peskett is GrowLikeGrandad (if you want to know why read 'About the Editor). He has a 'heavy clay' allotment and is a member of the Dorking Allotment Holders Association (DAHA). Matt also has a medium sized 'sandy soil' hillside garden (Italian terrace designed) and enjoys photography - especially nature. Matt takes inspiration from gardens like Hidcote, Great Dixter and Sissinghurst and enjoys watching anything on TV with Monty Don in it.

1 Comment

  1. Green manures are something I need to get better at. I keep thinking of having an Alfalfa patch to produce stuff I can either mulch with or compost, much like I do with comfrey.

Got any thoughts? Please share them with me here